Multifamily Probate SalesA guide by Shaya Lowenstein, Lyon Stahl Investment Real Estate Call (323) 944-2221

For executors, administrators, heirs and estate attorneys in Los Angeles County

Full or limited authority, and the Notice of Proposed Action

Full authority lets the personal representative sell the building without a court hearing, after giving a Notice of Proposed Action at least 15 days ahead. Limited authority leaves out the power to sell real property, so the court has to confirm the sale.

On this page
  1. What do full and limited authority mean?
  2. What does a Notice of Proposed Action have to say?
  3. How long is the objection window?
  4. What happens if a beneficiary objects?
  5. How does each route change the sale for buyers?
  • Your order for probate, form DE-140, states whether the court granted independent administration authority and whether that authority is full or limited.
  • Limited authority does not include selling real property, so a sale of the building needs court confirmation.
  • Under full authority, a Notice of Proposed Action states the price and the commission and goes out at least 15 days before the date it names.
  • A written objection or a restraining order that arrives in time sends the sale to the court, and the building then goes to a confirmation hearing.

What do full and limited authority mean?

Full and limited authority are the two levels of power the Independent Administration of Estates Act can give a personal representative, and the difference between them is real property. The Act is Part 6 of Division 7 of the Probate Code. Full authority includes every power it grants, section 10402. Limited authority includes all of them except the ones that touch real property, section 10403:

ActionFull authorityLimited authority
Sell real propertyIncluded, through the Notice of Proposed Action procedureNot included, needs court supervision
Exchange real propertyIncludedNot included, needs court supervision
Grant an option to buy real propertyIncludedNot included, needs court supervision
Borrow money secured by real propertyIncludedNot included, needs court supervision

Which one you hold is written on your order for probate, Judicial Council form DE-140, and the order may grant neither. Check it before you talk to anyone about listing the building. With only limited authority the sale will run through the court, and that decides how the listing is written, which offers are realistic and how long the calendar runs.

Full authority is what makes a sale without a hearing possible. Probate Code section 10503 lets the personal representative sell at public auction or by private sale, at a price and on terms of the personal representative's choosing, without a published notice of sale, court approval of the commission, the 90 percent minimum or a hearing on whether the sale is necessary. In their place is one document, the Notice of Proposed Action.

What does a Notice of Proposed Action have to say?

For a sale of real property, section 10585 requires the notice to state the material terms of the transaction, including the sale price and the amount of any commission or other compensation paid to an agent or broker, or the method used to calculate it. The procedure as a whole is in Probate Code sections 10580 through 10592, and Judicial Council form DE-165 is the form itself.

The notice goes to each known heir and each beneficiary under the will whose interest the sale would affect, to anyone who has filed a request for special notice, and to the Attorney General when part of the estate would pass to the state, as section 10581 provides. Sections 10582 and 10583 carve out exceptions, and the estate's attorney will know whether one fits your case.

A beneficiary deciding whether to object sees a price and a commission. If questions come, they are easier to answer with a short, factual record of how the building was marketed and what other offers came in. If Shaya is listing the building, he can keep that record as the listing runs, so the attorney is not answering from memory.

How long is the objection window?

Heirs and beneficiaries get at least 15 days with the notice before the sale can be made. Section 10586 requires it to be delivered, under section 1215, to each person entitled to it no less than 15 days before the date it names as the date on or after which the sale will be made. A mailed notice goes to the person's last known address.

An objection counts only if it arrives in time and takes a form the Probate Code recognizes. Under section 10587, a written objection has to be delivered or received at the address stated in the notice before the later of the date named in the notice and the date the sale is made. The recognized forms are these:

  • A written objection, delivered or mailed as section 10587 provides.
  • A restraining order from the court under section 10588, served within the time that section allows.

A phone call complaining about the price is not an objection. It is still worth taking seriously, because the person who is unhappy on day three can put it in writing on day twelve. Note who called and what they said, and pass it to the estate's attorney.

Write the window into the purchase contract as well. The buyer should know the date in the notice, and the contract should say what becomes of the deposit and the dates if an objection arrives.

What happens if a beneficiary objects?

An objection takes the sale out of your hands and puts it in front of the court. Section 10589 sets the rule. Once you have notice of a written objection or a restraining order, you may still go ahead, but only through the court-supervised procedure the sale would have needed if you held no independent authority. For a building, that means a sale reported to the court and confirmed at a hearing under Probate Code section 10308.

  • The objector is heard. Anyone who objected in writing or served a restraining order is entitled to notice of the hearing on the petition for confirmation.
  • The deal is open to overbids. Your accepted offer becomes the original bid at a confirmation hearing, where section 10311 lets other buyers top it and section 10309 applies the 90 percent floor. From there, the confirmation hearing and its overbid rules decide who buys.
  • Going ahead anyway puts your appointment at risk. Section 10589 lets the court remove a personal representative who takes the proposed action in violation of it.

The sale can survive an objection. What changes is who decides. When the objection is about price, the hearing is a fair place to settle it, since anyone who thinks the building is worth more can make a higher offer there. When it is about something else, such as an heir who wanted to buy the building or keep it, the question is legal and personal, and it belongs with the estate's attorney, because how to respond to an objection is legal advice and Shaya is not an attorney. What he can give the attorney is his read of what the building would bring from an outside buyer, which is the number a price objection is about.

How does each route change the sale for buyers?

Full authorityCourt confirmation
PriceNegotiated, and the 90 percent rule does not applyAt least 90 percent of an appraisal made within a year of the hearing
TermsAs the personal representative agrees, section 10503Conditional offers are generally not accepted in practice
Competition after acceptanceNone built inOpen overbidding at the hearing
Main waitThe notice period, at least 15 daysPublished notice of sale, the petition and the court's calendar
CommissionDisclosed in the noticeApproved by the court

Full authority gives the buyer more certainty, because no one can take the building from them at a hearing unless an objection sends the sale there. A confirmed sale gives the estate something in return for the wait, a public test of the price in front of a judge, and it loses the buyers who will not wait that long. Which trade suits your estate depends on your authority and on your family, and the estate's attorney can tell you which route is realistic before the building goes on the market.

Questions executors ask

What is the difference between full and limited authority in probate?

The difference is real property. Full authority carries every power the Independent Administration of Estates Act offers, and limited authority carries all of them except selling or exchanging real property, granting an option on it and borrowing against it, under Probate Code section 10403. An estate with limited authority needs the court to confirm a sale of its building.

How long do beneficiaries have to object to a Notice of Proposed Action?

At least 15 days, because Probate Code section 10586 requires the notice to go out that far ahead of the date it names. An objection is on time if it is delivered or received at the notice's address before that date or before the sale is made, whichever is later, under section 10587.

What happens if an heir objects to the sale?

The personal representative can still sell, but only through the court. Section 10589 requires the court-supervised procedure, which for a building means a confirmation hearing. The heir who objected is entitled to notice of it, and other buyers can make higher offers there.

Does a Notice of Proposed Action have to disclose the commission?

Yes. When the proposed action is a sale of real property, Probate Code section 10585 makes the commission one of the terms the notice must state, either as an amount or as the method for working it out, alongside the sale price.

Is there a minimum price in a full authority sale?

No floor applies, because Probate Code section 10503 lifts the 90 percent rule for a full-authority sale. What protects the family instead is the notice. It shows the price, so anyone who receives it can compare that price with the appraisal and object if it seems too low.

Confidential

Talk to Shaya about the building

Send the address and a line about where the case stands. Shaya will call you back to talk through the building, which route the sale is likely to take, and what the listing should have ready before the notice goes out or the hearing is set.

Rather talk now? Call or text (323) 944-2221Or email shaya@lyonstahl.com
Estate propertysellmymultifamilyinprobate.com

Shaya Lowenstein

About Shaya Lowenstein

Multifamily Real Estate Advisor · Lyon Stahl Investment Real Estate · CA DRE #01942326

Shaya Lowenstein has worked in real estate since 2011, across brokerage, operations and development. His practice is apartment buildings and land in Southern California: repositioning and value-add work, land use and zoning analysis, and long-range planning for owners, investors and developers.

Shaya is a licensed real estate agent. He is not an attorney or a tax advisor, and nothing on this site is legal or tax advice. When a decision turns on the law or on your taxes, talk to a California attorney or a CPA. How this guide is researched and kept current.

830 S Pacific Coast Hwy, Suite D-200, El Segundo, CA 90245(323) 944-2221shaya@lyonstahl.com